HDB charges 2.6% a year, and has for over two decades. Whether a bank loan beats it depends on how long you will hold the loan, and on several things that are not the rate at all.
You can move an HDB loan to a bank at any time. You cannot move a bank loan back to HDB: once the flat is on a bank loan, it stays with the banks. So the question is not only which is cheaper today, but whether you are ready to give up HDB’s rate for this flat for good.
| HDB loan | Bank loan | |
|---|---|---|
| Interest rate | 2.6% a year, set at 0.1% above the CPF Ordinary Account rate. That rate cannot fall below 2.5%, so HDB’s cannot fall below 2.6% | Usually fixed for the first two or three years, then floating with the market |
| How much you can borrow | Up to 75% of the price or valuation, whichever is lower. Your instalment is tested at 3% | Up to 75%. Your instalment is tested at 4% |
| Downpayment | 25%, from CPF, cash or both | 25%, at least 5% of it in cash |
| CPF savings | You must put in your Ordinary Account savings, keeping up to $20,000 | You decide how much to use |
| Loan length | Up to 25 years, and not past age 65 | Up to 30 years; the full 75% only on 25 years or less, ending by 65 |
| Paying it off early | No penalty | A penalty during the lock-in, the period you are tied to the bank |
| Who can have one | Citizens within HDB’s income ceiling, with an HFE letter (HDB’s letter saying whether you qualify, and for how much) | Anyone the bank approves |
Either way, the instalment on a flat may not exceed 30% of your monthly income: the mortgage servicing ratio.
HDB’s loan-to-value limit, how it has changed: Dec 2021, 90% → 85%; Sep 2022, 85% → 80%; Aug 2024, 80% → 75%, the same as the banks.
2.6% is rarely the lowest rate on offer, but it is the most predictable. Bank rates go where the market goes. Compounded 3-month SORA sat below 0.4% for most of the 2010s, rose to about 1.7% in 2019, fell back to near zero through 2020 and 2021, and climbed past 3.7% by 2023. A borrower who took a bank package in 2021 because it beat 2.6% was paying well above it two years later.
HDB tests your instalment at 3% rather than the banks’ 4%, which usually lets the same income borrow more. HDB’s loan also never charges you for paying it off early.
It also asks for less cash up front. HDB’s downpayment can come entirely from your CPF; a bank loan needs at least 5% of the price in cash, and for a new flat it is due when you sign the agreement for lease, typically within nine months of booking.
Selling or repaying within a few years. If you expect to sell the flat or clear the loan within about three to five years, a bank loan deserves a look. Many bank packages for HDB flats fix the rate for the first two or three years, so you know what you will pay for most of the time you hold the loan. Choose one whose lock-in (the period you are tied to the bank) ends before you expect to sell. Whether that fixed rate is below HDB’s 2.6% depends on the market when you borrow, so compare today’s packages rather than a rate someone quoted last year. The longer you expect to keep the loan, the more the years after the fixed period matter, and those float with the market rate.
A large CPF balance. HDB’s loan takes your Ordinary Account savings into the purchase, leaving you up to $20,000. Money taken out stops earning the CPF rate, and when you sell, you refund it to your account with the interest it would have earned. A bank loan leaves you to decide how much to use.
Buying your next flat after selling one. A second HDB loan comes after you have put in your CPF refund and part of the cash from the sale: you keep $25,000 or half the cash, whichever is more. A bank loan leaves that cash yours.
Above HDB’s income ceiling. Then a bank loan is the only one on offer, and the question becomes which bank.
Rules as set by HDB, the Monetary Authority of Singapore and the CPF Board. Your HFE letter and the bank’s own approval are what settle your case.
On this page
Ask an advisor
Want this worked out against your own numbers? Ask us. It’s free, and there’s no obligation.
Ask on WhatsApp